You're not doing a great job of not making me think you're speaking out of personal bias rather than fact:
Again, it would've been nice for you to clarify that this was your personal experience before and acknowledge that this is not necessarily a universally liberal idea. Additionally, you're now lumping liberals and democrats together as the same thing. Democrats are typically liberals (but not always) but liberals are definitely not always democrats. I'm not a democrat, I'm registered independent because I prefer to vote for issues, not parties.Originally posted by Only-now
Well, I did this because I don't believe the liberals that hold this point of view make up a minority of the group as a whole. I don't believe they are the "radicals". I believe they make up large enough of a portion to not have to differentiate them as being a minority. Also...to clarify things...I do not mean that liberals are completely against the idea of religion...but rather they are against the public display of it. I think that a majority of the leadership, and people who classify themselves as liberal hold this point of view. I could be wrong of course. Maybe it isn't the majority...but from my experience, and from the direction in which the actual democratic party is going...I don't think it is weird or outrageous to classify those that are part of that party as followers of that party's ideals.
So are you talking about liberals, or democrats?
If you want to make a good argument for something, generalizing entire groups of people, and being incredibly unspecific about just who you're talking about, is not the best way to go about it. It's offensive to those whom you're stereotyping and tends to suggest you don't really know what you're talking about and are just operating on a bias.
That explains it a little better, but I still disagree with your generalization that Europe is (which is not one single country at all) necessarily holds the same views as American Democrats (now that we've narrowed that down from "liberals.")I think I have made a mistake in explaining what I mean. The idea about religion we are discussing here is not a European invention, nor was it "imported" here. Left and Right wing thinkers exist everywhere...and this idea came from that side regardless of the continent or country of origin. I did not mean that those beliefs that Europeans hold...in terms of criticizing America for being too religious brought about the same beliefs here. I was stating...that Europe is generally more liberal than the United States. It holds views that the Democratic Party here (made up mostly of liberals as well) supports. One of these happens to be this view of religion. So...I believe that a large part of the world (Europe) holds the same liberal views that our Democratic Party supports here...thus they support one another belief wise. You will not believe the amount of times I have heard a liberal refer to the way "Europe" does something in comparison to how we do it. European ways have an influence and support liberal beliefs here.
Once again, as I've already asked several times, can you give me a specific example or some source other than "in my experience" that backs this generalization up?
I don't know this for a fact, but I suspect the recent attacks towards religion being displayed in public circumstances are the radical liberals' (key word "radical") reactions to the fact that religion has become increasingly more forceful and vocal in our society lately. My dad can attest that when he was a kid, the evolution debate wasn't an issue, for example. He learned about it in school and no one complained. Additionally, the recent gay rights movements have sparked a reaction from fundamentalist religious groups. In general, it's a time of heated debate for both sides as a result of a number of circumstances, but the point is, the views of the loud radicals who want these things done do not reflect the views of all liberals, nor does it suggest at all that America isn't religious enough these days, since in comparison to American citizens as a whole, these people are a dramatic minority.Alright..my mistake. I do not know whether it was protested at all before now. However, I do know that it has become a popular criticism recently. It was not the center of media discussion, laws, or nearly as much criticism in the past as it is now. I also know, that it was Americans that asked for it to be put there...and as far as I know...they hadn't asked for it removed or complained about it until now. True..someone might have...but it was never as large an idea then as it is now.
I specifically said every debate I've had with you, not every debate you've ever been in. I also never said that all of your arguments are only based on biases, I said this particular one seemed to be based on biases, since you've been spouting stereotypes this entire time (you even made the incredibly biased generalization that liberals = democrats and the two words can be used interchangeably).I am actually going to be 100% honest here. You are right. I do try to point out that I am done with a debate because I feel I do not have a good enough reply to respond to the current situation. In some cases I DO actually get tired of the argument..or I feel I have said all I can and don't actually WANT to discuss it anymore. I think it is wrong for you to say that I react this way in every argument..as there are quite a few where I stayed until no one posted anymore and everything had been said. You are also wrong that my arguments are only based on biases..as if yours are not? No one is free from this. I do hold some emotional feelings towards certain subjects...and I do not have extensive knowledge on every argument I make. I go on what I see, hear, read, etc. I do look up information and try to present a decent argument. The other thing is that I have no allies on this board other than Darkslash. What I mean by that...is that the majority of the people on this board disagree with my point of view. So...it is easy to feel rushed, or overwhelmed and even to lose confidence in your argument. When you have 20 people telling you you are wrong...and presenting very well thought out points (even if they are wrong)...it is not so easy to remain strong and confident that you can "win". So...I will stop saying that I am done with a topic unless I actually am. I feel bad about reacting the way I do honestly....so I will try to fix that.
In any case, I understand and respect your frustration, just remember that it's only going to make people like me more frustrated when you make claims and generalizations without checking your argument for logical flaws or checking the background on your statements. Whenever I state something as a fact in a debate, I check to make sure it actually is a fact first. That way I avoid issues like this.


Thanks: 


