Scar debate

[Nalinda]

As everyone knows, Scar is the villain of the movie TLK 1. Now, I wonder, what do everybody think of him?
Do you like/dislike him? Is he just missunderstood or a real villain?
What do you think?
I'll post my comments about him later, when I ain't so tired.

[Katse]

I see that you made this thread.XD

You already know that I <3 Scar.

[Sombolia]

Yay for making the thread. I think we spammed the screengrabs one enough.

I like him. I like him quite a lot, he's my favorite character I'll probably post later why exactly I think he's awesome.. of course, it's opinionated and largely based on my own filling in of plotholes, but it's at least better then "ong scar rulzez!" o_o

But first.. I need to eat. =9

[King Simba]

I seem to get the feeling that Scar is a misunderstood character. No idea why... just do. I sorta feel sorry for him at some points of the movie despite all the evil things he did. Anyway, we all know TLK won't be the same without our "evil villain uncle Scar." He adds a little more excitement to the movie as well as tension IMO.

EDIT: To me, Scar is a pretty cool character, don't get me wrong.

And good idea for the thread.

[Nalinda]

I'll post that tomorrow exactly why I don't like him.
But.. to start with. I won't bash him. Without him the movie wouldn't be the same.

[Katse]

I'll write more later, too. And you're right, Nalinda. TLK would be very different with Scar.

[Nephilim]

Scar is the best character in the film. I wouldn't bother with it, without him.

[Iestyn]

Scar is sexy! I heart him ^_^

[Katse]

Originally posted by Iestyn
Scar is sexy! I heart him ^_^

*High paws*

[Nalinda]

Haha, actually I think Simba is more sexy! AND KOVU! :kovusmile

[Sombolia]

Originally posted by Iestyn
Scar is sexy! I heart him ^_^

Ditto

I wouldn't bother with it, without him.

Ditto to that as well

[unregistered user]

What do I think of Scar.. hmm.. this is porbably the best thread I've read as of recent in this section of the forum, good idea

Anyway..

When I was a little kid I thought Scar was pure and absolute evil, especially where he's jumping through the fire to finish Simba off.

After reading all of those fan fics at TLKFAA though.. I don't know. I try to keep fandom and canon seperate, but that's me. I think canon Scar is evil. Fandom Scar though can range from pure evil to pure of heart

I personally believe that he was meant to be an evil character, the villain. I never questioned that until I found TLK fanbase xP

But yeah, Scar is definitely one of thee best Disney Villains ever made ^^

[Katse]

Originally posted by Nalinda
AND KOVU! :kovusmile

I have to agree with you on that one. Very sexy, indeed.

I used to think Scar was "lykomgtehEVILgoaway!!!11!" when I was younger, too. Ofcourse, I have a totally different opinion now.

[Lucy Lioness]

Originally posted by Iestyn
Scar is sexy! I heart him ^_^

Hehe. Rawr!

Mmm...well despite being the villain, I like him. He has a deep character, kinda like a tragic hero depending on how you look at him. And he is British!

[lion_roog]

Murderers always hold a special place in my heart....

[Sombolia]

Originally posted by Lucy Lioness
Mmm...well despite being the villain, I like him. He has a deep character, kinda like a tragic hero depending on how you look at him. And he is British!

That's kinda how I look on him too.. y'know, and sorry for making my, like, 5655000000000th post about SW, but he kinda reminds me of Anakin.. Anakin fell to the Dark Side, killed liked a bajillion people, attempted to kill even more (Luke included), but somehow, Luke still forgave him.. so it kinda makes me wonder what Simba would have done if Scar had redeemed himself in some way..

[Shatara]

I'm not a big Scar fan myself, but he is one of my (if not the) favorite villians. He's evil and vindictive and whatnot, but he seems more beliveable than a lot of Disney villans, who seem to be evil for the sake therof. You can actually analyze him and ask 'why is he like that?'


As for sexy-ness-ness, we ALL know that Vitani pwns all in that area

[Alli]

Originally posted by Sombolia
That's kinda how I look on him too.. y'know, and sorry for making my, like, 5655000000000th post about SW, but he kinda reminds me of Anakin.. Anakin fell to the Dark Side, killed liked a bajillion people, attempted to kill even more (Luke included), but somehow, Luke still forgave him.. so it kinda makes me wonder what Simba would have done if Scar had redeemed himself in some way..

I was thinking the same thing! Gosh, great minds think alike! But yeah, scar is one of my favorite characters...I mean, c'mon...Everybody always likes the good guys! What's wrong with being a lil evil :claw: :woeisme: :squash:

[Sombolia]

Originally posted by Alli
I was thinking the same thing! Gosh, great minds think alike! But yeah, scar is one of my favorite characters...I mean, c'mon...Everybody always likes the good guys! What's wrong with being a lil evil :claw: :woeisme: :squash:

That's why I love you. xP And yes, great minds do think alike.

[Sharifu]

Scar is an awesome villain! I like his design. Not only he is well animated by the amazing animator Andreas Deja, but his voice by Jeremy Irons was perfect for him.

I thought that maybe he was misunderstood growing up. But still I don't think that's a good excuse to kill your brother and nephew. (Well of course Simba never died, but that was apart of Scar's plan) I don't feel sorry for him for killing Mufasa though. He deserved his fate in the end.

But as a character, I think he is pretty cool.