I don't think there's been a thread like this one yet (I searched and it didn't come up with anything) but if there is, feel free to merge it.
My vote goes to both of them. I think both of them have their own different things that make them really stand out. :D The movie for its fantastic storyline, characters and animation, and the musical for its acts, music and the costumes.
So which do you guys prefer out of the two?